GamingExplainer

Loot boxes, paid currencies and pay-to-win: what the EU's Digital Fairness Act proposal means for games

The Commission's November 11 draft would bar paid loot boxes and pay-to-win offers for minors and make games show real-money values. Industry groups object.

By Gaming Desk · · 5 min read

The European Commission's proposal for a Digital Fairness Act (DFA), adopted in Brussels on November 11, 2026, would write rules on in-game spending into a regulation that would apply directly in every EU country. Three of its articles cover what the Commission calls “spending-maximising practices”: paid virtual currencies (Article 14), paid random rewards such as loot boxes (Article 15), and pay-to-win and pay-to-progress purchases (Article 16). A fourth, Article 17, would require tools that let users switch off features that encourage compulsive or excessive use. The text is a proposal for a regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council, to be adopted under the ordinary legislative procedure, so it is not law yet. Its final article says it would apply 12 months after it enters into force.

What the draft would require

In-game spending rules in the Digital Fairness Act proposal of November 11, 2026 (“minors” are people under 18; the stricter column applies where a product is directed at minors or the company knows with reasonable certainty that minors use it)
FeatureRule for all playersStricter rule for minors
Paid virtual currencies (Article 14)Show the money value, or an estimate, of items bought with the currencyCurrencies off by default; a parent or guardian must approve before they can be switched on
Paid loot boxes and other random rewards (Article 15)Disclose the types of items on offer and the probability of getting them; offer tools to switch them offNot offered to minors
Pay-to-win and pay-to-progress purchases (Article 16)No specific ruleNot offered to minors
Engagement features (Article 17)Tools to switch off autoplay, unprompted notifications, penalties for not engaging regularly and simulated relationships (the explanatory memorandum describes them as tools for users who are not minors)No rule in this article; on services the EU KIDS Act covers, that law's rules for minors apply instead

The currency rule covers currencies bought with money, directly or by exchanging another paid currency. The value must be given in the money the player first used to buy currency, and where it cannot be worked out directly, the draft's recitals say it may be estimated from the full price without bulk discounts or promotions. The recitals also say loyalty-program points are not virtual currency.

Loot boxes fall under the broader term “paid-for variable reward systems,” meaning virtual items offering random rewards or variable odds that are bought with money or paid currency. The recitals name loot boxes, wheels of fortune and collectible card packs, and say such systems “share the speculative features of gambling.” Pay-to-win and pay-to-progress mechanisms are defined as purchases that are necessary, or presented as necessary, to progress or succeed in a game or app. The recitals give artificial difficulty barriers, progression so slow that the free path is illusory and competitions effectively decided by spending as examples.

Some services are carved out of the currency-pricing rule and the loot-box ban for minors because the proposed EU KIDS Act would set its own obligations for them: social networks, video-sharing platforms, AI companions and general conversational chatbots. Our explainer on the KIDS Act covers those proposals.

When a game counts as directed at minors

The stricter rules turn on whether a product is directed at minors or the company is aware with reasonable certainty that minors use it. The recitals say this should be judged on objective indicators, among them age checks, customer accounts, age ratings and marketing that appeals to children. One example they give: a product is directed at minors where it carries an age rating indicating that it is appropriate for people under 18, whether the rating comes from the company itself, from app stores under the KIDS Act, from the Pan-European Game Information (PEGI) system or from a comparable scheme. A company is treated as aware that a player is a minor where the player's account lets it establish that, directly or indirectly.

The industry's objections

The European Games Developer Federation (EGDF), which says it represents more than 2,500 studios through 24 national trade associations, and Video Games Europe answered on the day of publication with a joint statement calling the proposal “unworkable, unjustified and disproportionate.” They argue that age ratings “indicate suitability, not target audience,” and that treating every game rated below PEGI 18 as directed at children risks pushing an 18-plus threshold onto almost all game features. They say the pay-to-win ban lacks clear definitions and could cover “almost any purchase in a game,” and that the draft would ban virtually all in-game purchases for under-18s, leaving parents and teenagers no say.

The two groups point to measures the industry already runs: PEGI, which they say is used in 40 countries and which this year, alongside Germany's USK, widened its rating criteria to take in-game purchases and paid random items into account, and parental controls on console, PC and mobile platforms. They describe their own proposals: purchases and online communication switched off by default for children unless a parent turns them on, clear real-money prices, refunds for unused currency and smaller top-ups. On currencies, they say the industry's proposals were not considered, and they are concerned that price-transparency rules carried over from the EU consumer authorities' key principles on in-game currencies will mislead players.

The Commission's reasoning

The draft's recitals give the Commission's case. Paid currencies make it harder for players to judge what a purchase really costs, and the recitals say minors may find the real value particularly hard to understand. Random rewards can cause unwanted spending, and pay-to-progress designs can create pressure to pay that minors find hard to resist. The Commission says its public consultation drew 3,341 responses, covered features of products such as video games, and showed substantial support for further EU action. Its impact estimates for the preferred option as a whole, not only the gaming rules, put the reduction in financial harm to consumers at €88.4 billion over 2025 to 2035 and recurring costs for businesses at €678 million a year after adjusting for overlaps.

Penalties would be set nationally, but under the draft's penalties article, Article 35, the maximum fine for widespread infringements handled through coordinated EU enforcement must be at least 4% of the company's annual turnover in the countries concerned, and in cases the Commission investigates itself under a revised consumer-enforcement regulation proposed alongside the DFA, it could fine up to 6% of worldwide annual turnover.

From proposal to law

The proposal now needs the agreement of the European Parliament and the Council under the ordinary legislative procedure, and until a final text applies, none of its rules binds game companies. If it is adopted, its final article says it would enter into force on the twentieth day after publication in the EU's Official Journal and apply 12 months after that; the documents we read give no timetable for adoption. How EU consumer authorities read current law for in-game currencies is set out in our explainer on their principles and enforcement, and how Australia classifies games with paid loot boxes in our explainer on Australian classification.

Sources

  1. Proposal for a Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council on promoting fair business-to-consumer commercial practices in the offline and digital single market (Digital Fairness Act), COM(2026) 1100 final European Commission, November 11, 2026
  2. Digital Fairness Act European Commission, November 11, 2026
  3. Joint statement from the European Games Developer Federation (EGDF) and Video Games Europe (VGE) on the Digital Fairness Act European Games Developer Federation (EGDF), November 11, 2026

Researched and drafted with AI assistance, then checked against the 3 sources above in a separate fact-check on November 16, 2026. Spotted an error? Tell us.